BC Hydro will proceed with its smart meter program regardless of growing municipal government opposition, Energy Minister Rich Coleman said Tuesday.
As local government officials at the Union of B.C. Municipalities Convention grilled BC Hydro officials over why the utility is proceeding with the controversial $930-million infrastructure upgrade program despite concerns from residents, Coleman said the program is here to stay.
“We continue what we are supposed to do, and that is to install smart meters in British Columbia,” he said. “We have already made the investment, we’ve already passed the legislation in the Clean Energy Act. We have invested [as much as] $400 million so far and a resolution [by the UBCM] is not going to stop us.”
The province has insisted BC Hydro convert and upgrade its meter system to devices that can be read remotely. It estimates the program will result in a net savings of $520 million over 20 years and lead to improved conservation of electricity. It will also put a significant damper on electricity theft from marijuana-growing operations.
Local politicians at a breakfast seminar expressed a repeated theme that their ratepayers have concerns about potential health impacts from the radio frequency (RF) emitting devices. Others worried the meters will collect more private information than simple usage statistics.
Others believe BC Hydro will eventually use the meters to bring in “time of use” rates that, while offering cheaper rates in non-peak hours, will dramatically raise rates in peak evening hours. Several pointed to the experience of residents in California and Ontario, whose monthly bills rose by as much as 80 per cent because of the time-scaled rates.
“In respect to issues in our community, this one has been pretty tremendous,” said Chris Burger, Parksville’s acting mayor. The municipality has its own utility but buys power from BC Hydro and is part of the smart meter program.
“We are getting letters being sent to our utility from customers saying they will refuse to accept smart meters,” he told the session. “They have also said they will refuse to allow personnel from entering their property to install these meters.”
A number of people believe the devices can cause cancer because they emit radio signals. But BC Hydro project manager Gary Murphy said the meters produce a tiny fraction of energy compared to cellphones and other ubiquitous wireless devices.
He said B.C. residents won’t be allowed to opt out of the program or use non-smart meter equipment, although BC Hydro is willing to consider moving the meters elsewhere on a property. “We continue to have a dialogue with those folks and we are trying to answer all their questions,” he said. “We are not in a place where we are ready to throw the gauntlet down and play hardball.”
Wendy Bales, a director for the Fraser Valley Regional District, said some of her constituents are so angry and worried they are considering “going off the grid” by installing their own power generation equipment.
Under questioning from Saanich Coun. Leif Wergeland, Murphy acknowledged BC Hydro never consulted with the public before buying the meters. He said the province’s Clean Energy Act mandated that the utility begin the modernization program.
Murphy said the province is not bringing in “time of use” rates, something Coleman reinforced with reporters later.
Asked why there is a backlash against the program, Murphy blamed part of it on “the anti-RF specialty groups that grew out of Northern California.”
jefflee@vancouversun.com
twitter.com/sunciviclee
© Copyright (c) The Vancouver Sun
Read more:
BC Hydro won't be dissuaded on smart meters: Rich Coleman